Short Strides and Odd Thoughts: Feeling Sorry

It was safe to say the previous post was eventually going to get a sequel and this is it.  I had a lot of people, coaches and others whose personal choices are in question if they are reading my blog, with thoughts on “The (Sorry) State of D3 Cross Country.”  And while all of the commentary was positive for the post, everyone was similarly concerned about the issue at hand.  Which lends itself to the question of what to do about it?

That’s a question easy to ask but harder to answer.  Again, in order to answer the question we need to recognize the challenges we are facing in the sport, and then drill down to what avenues we have to confront it where it’s happening.  We can see that enrollment in sport is lower in Division 3, and likely across at least the high school spectrum, but simply recognizing the problem does very little, if anything, to resolve it.  So let’s look at the potential hurdles to obtaining and retaining athletes in cross country (and track and field) individually.

I think the first issue in the loss of participation is simply the declining number of students enrolled in our public schools.  I know when I started teaching at Mascenic we had 425 students enrolled in a three town regional system.  In the interim, Mason left the district, taking its 10 or so students per grade and went to Milford.  That alone doesn’t account for our current 265 student enrollment.  Covid helped move a number of them to homeschooling, something that had been around in our district for some time, but certainly shifting the needle more specifically in 2020.  I’m not sure how this has affected other districts as we had already had a large homeschool contingent.  Also remember, these students still get to participate in sports at the high school and do regularly, with our golf team made up at least half with homeschoolers.  But it’s safe to say declining enrollment isn’t just a local phenomena and is likely affecting total participation across all divisions.

I think another factor, maybe specific to our district, is low energy around the sport with relation to our athletic department.  I know in talking with other coaches that I am not alone with this issue, but conversations across the state indicate interest in promoting the sport within the guise of high school offered athletics varies, with some schools getting great support and others with less so.  It is my opinion through observation, that at smaller schools, with smaller budgets and smaller sport offerings, cross country and track and field, and other lower visibility sports like swimming or skiing, there is less attention by the athletic department to these sports.  And I suppose it makes sense that the less mainstream sports with less visibility get less attention, but that doesn’t make it right.  Sure baseball, or basketball, or soccer, or field hockey or volleyball have an easier time attracting fans, with the spectator being able to watch all of the action all of the time, but that doesn’t mean there is no room for promotion of these other sports offered, even if under-supported.

Now I don’t want to create a big stir amongst under-supported sports practitioners and coaches, being against our athletic departments isn’t going to do anything good for anyone.  But I do think we need to identify where our sport is under-supported, bring it to the attention of our athletic departments and administration to work together to find an appropriate solution.  In some cases it might be simply to help them recognize the value of our sport, to community, other coaches and to the students, as an important part of the educational process.  This past weekend I was talking to a coach who read my article and passed it onto their athletic director to create a dialogue around a solution for their district and the AD was responsive – good sign.

However I see two potential hurdles with respect to having these conversations with athletic directors.  First is, I do not imagine there are many athletic directors out there who were primarily cross country athletes.  This means the more visible Sports Illustrated-type sports are where they are most comfortable.  They enjoy athletics when it pertains to their sense of sport.  Much like anyone else unaccustomed to our sport, athletic directors, while overseeing all the sports a school offers, is going to be more focused on those they enjoy, or bring them success.  And success and winning may not be the same thing.  Community visibility is worth its weight in gold and our sport tends to see little of it.

Another hurdle is funding, and with small budgets and concerns about school funding, I think athletic directors are discretionary with the money and it tends to go to the sports they understand.  Oftentimes our sport is looked at through the lens of all you need is a uniform and you can compete, which is partially true.  I recall in my one year as Mascenic’s AD the request for golf balls for the season being $800.  I’m not saying golf doesn’t need golf balls, and when you are chasing championships you want to use the best balls you can, but the cross country/indoor/outdoor track uniforms were getting updated maybe every five years to the tune of less than that.  $800 divided by five years, and then 3 seasons per year gets you to just under $55 per season.  Certainly a substantial savings.

But as that relates to the student athletes, they see the under-investment in their sport.  It’s natural to want to go where there is greater interest and investment.  Riding over to MOCs Saturday I asked an athlete if they were aware of the snub and they said most definitely.  If a different sport is getting the acknowledgement and accolades, and it’s human nature to seek that, it’s going to be hard to recruit greater numbers.  I’m not saying our sport needs more bling, but it could use a boost in the recognition area for sure.  I know this is true of our district and conversations I’ve had over the years indicate that to be true other places as well.

I also think of two other hurdles that if enhanced and embraced by athletics and the school administration, would improve participation and overall improved athletics.  Let’s look at participation first.  Cross country and more so track and field, can accommodate just about the entire student body.  Now we don’t want to turn the sport into afterschool babysitting, but any athlete that wants to come and participate certainly can with a well developed cross country or track program.  We’ve had plenty of athletes come out for the sport with ambitions other than sporting excellence.  Maybe they want it for college applications, maybe they just want to be part of a team, maybe they want to get in shape for their primary sport, maybe they have friends on the team and are only there for the socializing.  These are all good reasons for athletic departments to embrace these sports.

The other is the general improvement in athletics for the greater good of the school.  Traditionally at Mascenic most sports and some of the coaching staff have tried to steer their athletes away from cross country and track and field for concerns they might lose an athlete to these running sports.  With small numbers themselves they are protective of their athletes and overly so.  What they are missing is even if they lost someone, the rest of their athletes that participated have either strengthened their endurance or another skill that will enhance their play in their sport.  Yes, you may lose a player or two every once and again, but let’s face it if you lose an athlete to endurance running they belonged there to begin with and it’s better for that athlete.

Put these two together, a push for all students to contemplate a sport, with the default sports being cross country, swimming, skiing and track and field (unlimited roster spots), AND a push for athletes to compete in these sports and that would be a positive for our enrollment in the very least.  Not sure it would necessarily improve the quality of competition, but you can’t compete without having five on the line so I see that as an advancement over where we are now.  I’ve always said, give me three freshmen per year and I’ll put a competitive team on the line.  With approximately half of the schools in D3 not being able to do that, five on the line, it’s safe to say the competition wouldn’t be that strong.

I think another hurdle is not having the capacity to recruit within a school.  If there isn’t someone advocating for the sport to the students during their day to day lives, there isn’t going to be much interest.  If the coach isn’t in the school, or at least the district, recruiting and having strong numbers is going to be extremely difficult.  For this to be true, athletics needs to seek out potential coaching candidates within the school/district population, make a strong pitch for how sports are good for a student’s overall growth, then support those coaches in the work they are doing with their athletes.  Coaches are role models, and hiring the right people to do so is paramount.  I think often at the Division 3 level ADs are scrambling to fill these positions, often happy to have a body to fill the spot with little regard to their proficiency at the sport.  Not saying a coach has to be a world class athlete, but they need to recognize the needs of their athletes beyond the day to day workouts.  They need to be invested outside the 11 weeks of the season. 

 And they need the support of the athletic department, the school and the district as well.  It’s not enough simply to hire someone to hopefully do “good stuff” but help them become a better role model and better facilitator of the sport they coach.  It’s the ADs job to support all the sports a district offers equally, and help the coaches engage in furthering their technical expertise and professional growth.  It’s telling about the amount of schools that do not have representation at the NH Track and Field Coaches Association Clinic coming up on November 21st, again particularly at the D3 level.  Here’s a free opportunity for professional advancement that many of our coaches simply do not know about even though their schools are being notified of it.  Again, I’m afraid of a little too much out of sight, out of mind, due to the low visibility of our sport among the other NHIAA sports.

Once again I’m three pages into a blog post and feel the need to wrap this one up.  However I know I’m not quite done, a promised conversation with my colleague Zach Emerson for some thoughts of how schools and communities can work towards a solution to build and support this sport we love.  And while I feel we can help develop a solution, it’s going to come down to whether the schools and communities can commit to tackling the issue, rather than simply let things run their course.  I’m down for the action, let’s hope we can gain some traction and take a step forward, rather than be content taking a step back.

I’ll see you out there.

Discover more from NHXCTF

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Division I & II Championship Meet Time Changes

ALL field events will now start at 11:00am (including pole vault). Pole Vault will combine divisions and will begin when the rain has stopped.

Running events will begin at 12:30pm.

8:00am D1 schools arrive (Buses drop off and then park at Plymouth Elementary school)

9:00 Field Events start

10:30 Running Events start

1:15ish D1 meet ends

1:15-2:15 D1 buses pick up teams in the circle 

3:15pm D2 schools arrive (Do not arrive early. Buses drop off and then park at Plymouth Elementary school)

4:15 Field Events start

5:45 Running Events start

8:30ish D2 meet ends

8:30 D2 buses pick up teams in the circle

All meets have been moved to Saturday. Please click here to see the updated schedule.